The Federal Communications Commission eventually moved to adopt what has come to be known as Net Neutrality regulations. However, some commissioners are worried that the adoption of the new Internet rules could mean more harm than good to the public. FCC seems to be a dividend house at this point given that the chairman of the federal communications agency believes that reclassifying the Internet as a utility is a positive move.

When FCC commissioners came up to vote in the new Internet regulations, the voting fell right along the party lines. It happened that three Democrat commissioners voted for the changes to Internet regulation while two Republican Commissioners voted against the new regulations. The FCC Democrat Chairman, Tom Wheeler, voted for the new Internet rules.

FCC Commissioners say Net Neutrality creates room for new internet taxes

Stage for new taxes
According to the dissenting commissioners, Ajit Pai and Michael O’rielly, there is something dangerous in the reclassification of the Internet as a utility. The obvious thing, they noted, is that the adoption of Net Neutrality will open up opportunities for new Internet taxes, hurting the consumers. The two commissioners acknowledged that this may not happen immediately, but the stage is already set.

Government intrusion
In his dissenting note, Pai stated that Net Neutrality actually brings government control into what should otherwise be a force for freedom. According to Pai, government intrusion into a powerful freedom tool such as the Internet would not solve a thing.

Pai further noted that since the passage of the Telecommunications Act of 1996, no FCC chairman, regardless of the party affiliation, has allowed the regulation of the Internet as a utility. The telecommunications Act of 1996 sought to make the Internet a free and vibrant market that is unfettered by state or federal regulations.
On his part, O’rielly termed the reclassification of the Internet as a Title II utility as an unlawful power grab.
FCC chairman defends move
Specifically, the dissenting FCC commissions believe that the reclassification of the Internet will bring new taxes at the federal, state and local levels to the Internet consumers. However, commission chairman, Wheeler, disagrees. In fact, FCC published a document that seeks to separate facts from fiction in the Net Neutrality debate.

3 Responses

  1. hipposelect

    Well, WHO on EARTH would have guessed that 400 pages of regulations of something that was heretofore unregulated would open the door to more taxation? You can just knock me over with a feather! SURE didn’t see THAT coming, did YOU?

  2. mitharus

    ” … no FCC chairman, regardless of the party affiliation, has allowed the regulation of the Internet as a utility.”

    Yes, and Congress threatened to strip the FCC of its power if they used their full authority when the 2010 Open Internet rules were created. In fact, Congress tried to overturn those same rules.

    I’m sorry, but Pai with his “Here’s these rules you can’t read!” knowing full well that the FCC doesn’t release it’s rules prior to a vote lost all credibility. Yes we *should* have been able to read them before the vote, but he knew full well that most people don’t know the FCC rules, and would think that the rules were being hidden from them, when in fact, it is SOP for the FCC to not release them.


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.